Is it Brain Drain or Forex Source?
| Is it a brain drain or forex source? | ![]() |
![]() |
| Written by Prof Makinda | |
| 10-August-2007:In the past few weeks, several reports have raised important questions about the effects of Kenyans abroad on the national economy. Two recent reports published by the United Nations Conference on Trade and Development (UNCTAD and the International Monetary Fund (IMF) attribute different types of impact to the Kenyan diaspora. The UNCTAD report highlights the loss of human resources through emigration or the brain drain.The idea of a brain drain is not new and is predicated on the wrong assumption that Kenyans who live and work abroad are a loss to the country.This concept is also partly discriminatory. While our nationals who live and work in the US, the UK, South Africa and other countries are considered a “brain drain†irrespective of their reasons for working there, those who work for international agencies, such as the United Nations, the African Union and the World Bank are generally not considered a brain drain.Claims of a brain drain do not take serious account of the globalisation of labour, which means people can provide services anywhere in the world irrespective of where they live. These claims also ignore the significance of pull and push factors at play. Moreover, Kenyans who live and work abroad relate to Kenya differently. Some have opened up business opportunities for Kenyan traders in places like Uganda and southern Sudan, others have become millionaires through property development in places like South Africa and are investing their profits in Kenya, while others promote or defame Kenya in different ways. These people are too diverse to be placed in one basket. Through investments in stocks and the real estate market, in addition to support for relatives, Kenyans submit about one billion dollars per year. From the perspective of remittances alone, one could conclude that Kenyans abroad are doing their country a great service. Both the UNCTAD and IMF reports raise important questions for Kenya’s political leadership and employers. If we are serious about addressing the so-called brain drain, we need employers who are ready to provide attractive and competitive salaries and working conditions. Creating these conditions is the responsibility of both political leaders and the captains of industry. It is a matter of enlightened governance. Let us take the case of the doctors’ strike in the 1990s. Some of their demands were about ordinary equipment, which their colleagues in other countries took for granted. Had the Government been prepared to meet their demands, Kenya would have more doctors than it currently has. As the Kenya government was not willing to meet the doctors’ demands, South Africa was only too willing to offer them what they wanted and more. To stem the departure of our nurses, doctors, researchers, airline workers and other specialists, we need to review the conditions of work. In other words, we have to address both the push and pull factors. Prof Makinda is the chair of Security, Terrorism and Counterterrorism, Murdore university Australia |
Posted: August 11th, 2007 under Business News.
Comments: none


Write a comment